My mail server is serving 4 domains for sending (even more for receiving). I have DKIM configured for the 4 sending domains.

A couple of years ago, before DKIM was implemented in Mercury, I added areplymod daemon from @Rolf Lindby and set the address for the auto-replies to get around the problem that gmail was requiring a non-empty from address in the envelope, using the the primary domain in the address.

Now, I'm seeing that auto-replies fail for all but the primary domain. I believe the problem is that DKIM is not applied to auto-replies. And with DMARC configured with SPF and DKIM, if the envelope header From address does not match the auto-reply From address, and the auto-reply is not DKIM signed, the auto-reply is rejected.

I haven't tried disabling Rolf's daemon, but before I do that, I thought I'd ask if anybody knows a solution for getting DKIM signing on auto-replies.

Tony

The beta test team has also reported this issue to me. After an initial inspection of the code, I can't see why it would be happening, but I am looking into it. Once I find the solution, I'll bring out a patch quickly.

Cheers!

-- David --

Hello David, Tony,

I am in the "same boat" as Tony, using Rolf's auto-reply daemon and planning to upgrade to the beta and implementing DKIM. As it will be in a few month time (winter) I just wanted to let you know that there is one more user with this auto-reply daemon.

Johannes

Just a quick note that I've worked out what's going on here, and should have a fix soon. It'll need a brief period in beta, then I'll release it as soon as we're sure it's working as intended.

Cheers!

-- David --

Hello David,

Thank you for your quick actions. Very much appreciated!

Hopefully the result will be positive, but I am sure it will. Waiting for the result.

Johannes